| Platinum | Little Italian Pizza |
| Platinum | Roosterfish Grill |
| Gold | Your Pizza Shop |
| Silver | Acropol Family Restaurant |
| Bronze | Pizza Shack Italian Grille |
| Top Pick | Amish Country Store |
| Top Pick | D.O.D. Coffee Roastery |
| Top Pick | Finley's Irish Pub & Eatery |
| Corner Bar & Grill | |
| Frida's Cafe & Bakery | |
| Sages West Bay Bistro | |
| Sahara Mediterranean Fine Wine & Food | |
| Seminole Subs & Gyros |