| Platinum | Da Pollani's |
| Platinum | Your Pizza Shop |
| Gold | Untouchables Pasta & Pizza |
| Silver | Forchetta Italian Eatery |
| Bronze | Amici Italian Eatery |
| Top Pick | Acropol Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Bro's Pizzeria & Bar |
| Top Pick | Ippolito Italian Deli |
| Top Pick | Pie12 Napoletana Coal Fired Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Pizza Shack |
| Sages West Bay Bistro |